Note-this post was originally written in 02/02/2012. It sat in the draft section for a year and I finally put it up.
I was driving to the supercenter with Tim tonight, to buy small, round, Ziplock containers, the kind with the screw top. Tim commented on how specific I was in my requirements for these lunch containers. I explained how they're the right shape and size, and how the screw top lids were essential to prevent spills in my bag.
That got us talking about specificity. We have a staggering array of goods and services available to us to meet every requirement.What did people do before Tupperware? Even I remember putting something in the fridge with a piece of cling wrap and an elastic over it. Now, I won't settle for just any, plastic containers. Ho no, I have to have precisely the right size and shape for each application, including specs for the lids.
We had to go out, in the car, on a mission for the right lids. It was as if I wouldn't eat, if I couldn't find the right container for the food. And me, with all my sarcasm about phthalates and my disgust with landfills.
The thing is, this culture of specificity has much bigger implications than storing leftovers. We're "hothousing" our children, reading them flashcards in the womb and micro planning their days to tailor them for success in the world of specificity. We're choosing our mates based on an ever more specific list of requirements. It won't be long until we'll have the capability of building our children from the DNA-up. And shortly thereafter, we'll have the desire to do it.
We're a species of specificity. Jarred Diamonds's Guns, Germs and Steel postulates that "successful" cultures have benefited from a specific combination of factors, right down to latitudes with environmental advantages. Specialization had led to specificity, the macro reflected in the micro.What we generally imagine as progress in the western world, has been a process of increasing specificity.
In evolutionary terms, specialization has meant the successful adaptation of many organisms on this planet, and it's also been the undoing of that many more. Just ask the dodo. Sometimes the devil really is in the details. Remember the blackout of 2002, that left most of our northeastern seaboard with no power for three days? Luckily for us, it was the summer, but even so, most of us were as helpless as kittens. How would we have fared if a massive solar flare had fried the entire continental power grid for a year? Would I really have cared about the specifics of my lunch containers?
Thursday, March 14, 2013
Do Not Suspend Your Disbelief
Anyone who has cable has got to have noticed the latest
assault from corporate television—the pop-up ad in the TV show. Finally, the
commercials are over and you’re back to your show—but no! In the middle of a tense
scene, you have to view an ad for some other show on their network, or some new smartphone. Screw-off, already! We’re paying for cable, which should be
free, since the hourly content contains 18 minutes of ads, and now you won’t
let us suspend our disbelief for ten minutes without throwing something else up
on the screen. A couple of times these ads have even obscured the action in a
scene. The networks don’t employ a modicum of consideration when placing them,
piling insult on top of injury.
I might have to start a petition. If we don’t stop this we
might as well turn all content, everywhere, into 100% advertising. What I fear,
is that people will actually tolerate that, and learn to like it. The
percentage of ad content on television has grown, to say nothing of the visual
blanketing of our physical world in consumer images. What’s more, while
television ads have gotten progressively shorter, there’s more of them, inundating
our consciousness with trivia that competes for headspace with worthwhile thinking.
And we complain that kids can’t focus.
Our brains are tired. I hear people talk about it all the
time—how hard it is mentally, to just exist. The emotional complexity of being
human, which should be a gift, is often a demoralizing burden when our
relationships and our very identities are assaulted by advertising which
relentlessly points out our unmet “needs”.
Fulfilling these “needs” has turned us into debt-slaves, and we don’t
know what the point of anything is, anymore.
I wonder if consumerism is all that’s left of western
culture. I have friends who think that western culture has been an ethically
and spiritually bankrupt system from its inception, and good riddance. As I
write this, I’m inclined to agree. You could view the current state of affairs
not as a decline, but an evolution, since western culture was historically built on a set of violently
elitist principles that made this corporate world order inevitable and
desirable by its own stated values. Consumerism as twenty-first century slavery. The
more things change, the more they stay the same.
Are we in a state of decline? Pundits have been saying so
for centuries. Classical philosophers and their neo-classical groupies
romanticized the life of the simple shepherd, out in the fresh air, watching
the clouds go by, not a care in the world save his docile flock. I suspect it
wasn’t that easy being a shepherd, and that given an opportunity to flick a
switch and have light, or a hot bath and a meal whenever he wished, he’d
hang-up his hook in a heartbeat, as would half the world now who still lives
that way.
Would our time-warped shepherd mind the pop-up ad in his
show? I’m not a sheep herder and I couldn’t begin to guess. Indoor plumbing is
one thing, advertising is another. But I am a sheep, like the rest of us who
complain about this kind of thing and still tune-in. And if the wanton
proliferation of advertising, consumerism, debt and never-ending work days
marks the decline of my culture, then I’m going down with it, unless I can find
another way to live within this system. Or, I can just watch the ads, watch my
debt, watch my email, and wait for it all to blow-up.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)